top of page

Is Expensive Skincare Worth It? A Beauty Industry Insider’s Take

Writer: Peachtree Beauty
Peachtree Beauty
Oct 4
6 min read

After close to two decades working in the cosmetic and personal care industry, there is one question I probably get asked more than any other:


“Is it actually worth buying the expensive stuff?”


My answer?


Sometimes.


I know. Very helpful.


But just like cars, clothing, food, electronics, and almost every other consumer product category, I believe spending more can get you a better product. The problem is that the improvement in performance is rarely proportional to the increase in price.


A product that costs twice as much is probably not twice as effective.


A product that costs ten times as much is almost certainly not ten times better.


Of course, there will always be exceptions on both ends of the spectrum. But for simplicity, let's leave the unicorns out of this conversation.


And before we go any further, one disclaimer: this article represents my personal perspective based on my industry experience and finite knowledge. It is not intended to be a comprehensive scientific analysis or medical advice.


With that out of the way, let's talk about expensive skincare.


Does Higher Price Mean Higher Quality?


Consumers naturally associate higher prices with higher quality.


There is actually a name for this in consumer-behavior research: the price-quality heuristic. When we don't have enough information to judge a product objectively, we often use price as one of the clues.


It costs more, so it must be better.


The problem is that research has repeatedly shown that price can be a surprisingly weak indicator of actual product quality in many categories.


There is even beauty-specific evidence worth considering.


A 2017 study published in JAMA Dermatology evaluated 174 best-selling moisturizers and found an enormous range in price—from $0.10 to $9.51 per ounce, a 9,400% difference. Yet products without the potential allergens evaluated in the study were not significantly more expensive than products containing one or more of them. The authors also noted the lack of good comparative evidence showing that more expensive moisturizers were more effective.


That does not mean expensive moisturizers are bad.


It means price alone doesn't tell you very much.


So What Are You Paying For?


This is where I think the discussion gets more interesting.


When you buy a prestige beauty product, you are not necessarily paying only for greater efficacy.


You may also be paying for:


  • More elegant texture and sensory experience

  • Premium fragrance

  • More sophisticated packaging and dispensing systems

  • Expensive or proprietary ingredients

  • Specialized formulation technologies

  • Clinical or consumer testing

  • Smaller-volume or more complicated manufacturing

  • Branding, advertising, sampling, retail displays, and marketing

  • And, yes, the prestige of owning the product


None of those things are automatically worthless.


If an elegant texture makes you enjoy applying your moisturizer every night, there is value in that.


If beautiful packaging makes the product feel special and gives you a little enjoyment every morning, there is value in that too.


Luxury products do not have to justify their existence purely through measurable skin improvement.


Nobody asks whether a $5,000 handbag holds your wallet 100 times better than a $50 handbag.


But we should at least understand what we are paying for.


Think About Food


I often explain it using food.


If you are starving and fast food is the only thing available, buying it probably makes sense.


If you have options and can comfortably afford something healthier and tastier, spending a little more may be worthwhile.


But now go to the opposite extreme.


Is dinner at a Michelin-starred restaurant ten times tastier or ten times more nutritious than dinner at a good neighborhood restaurant just because the bill is ten times higher?


Probably not.


But that doesn't mean the Michelin-starred meal isn't worth it.


You may be paying for the ingredients, creativity, execution, atmosphere, service, rarity, presentation, and experience.


Beauty works similarly.


I'm Not Saying Buy the Cheapest Product Either


This is not an argument for buying the least expensive thing you can find.


Think about buying a car.


You don't need a Ferrari or Lamborghini to get from Point A to Point B safely, reliably, comfortably, and even with a little style.


But I also wouldn't recommend buying the cheapest car you can find if the check-engine light is on, smoke is coming out of the hood, and the seller says, “Don't worry about that noise.”


There is a very large middle ground between cheap and luxury.


The same is true in beauty.


My advice is usually to find reputable products that are appropriate for your skin, contain ingredients relevant to what you are trying to accomplish, and most importantly, fit comfortably into a routine you can maintain.


The $200 Gym Membership Problem


Here's another analogy I use all the time.


A $200-per-month gym membership will not get you into shape if you never go.


The same principle applies to skincare.


You can buy the most beautiful $300 cream in the department store, but if you are afraid to use it because every scoop feels like you're withdrawing money from your retirement account, what exactly did you accomplish?


Meanwhile, someone consistently using a well-formulated moisturizer and sunscreen may be doing something considerably more useful for their skin.


The American Academy of Dermatology actually recommends starting an anti-aging routine with sunscreen and moisturizer, calling them two of the most effective anti-aging products people can buy. It also emphasizes giving products time to work and continuing to use them if you want to maintain the results.


There is good clinical evidence behind that consistency argument too.


In a randomized controlled trial involving 903 adults, participants assigned to regular daily sunscreen use showed 24% less skin aging over 4.5 years than those using sunscreen at their own discretion.


Not exactly the sexiest beauty message in the world.


But sometimes the boring answer is the useful answer.


Consistency Beats Occasional Luxury


So if someone asks me where I would spend my skincare budget, I would generally prioritize:


A good routine that I can comfortably maintain.


Cleansing appropriately.


Moisturizing.


Sun protection.


Then adding targeted, evidence-supported ingredients for the concerns that actually matter to you.


For example, retinoids have substantial evidence behind their use for concerns such as acne, pigmentation, texture, fine lines, and wrinkles, but they also need to be appropriate for the individual and used correctly.


I would also slightly challenge one common beauty idea: your skin doesn't need new products simply because it has “gotten used to” the old ones.


There isn't a good reason to constantly rotate effective products just to keep your skin surprised.


That said, there is nothing wrong with occasionally adding something new because your needs changed, you want to target another concern, or (quite simply) you enjoy beauty products.


You are allowed to have fun.


Marketing Is Part of the Product


Whether we like it or not, beauty is an industry heavily influenced by marketing, emotion, aspiration, and perception.


And I say that as someone who makes a living in this industry.


The formula matters.


Testing matters.


Safety matters.


Efficacy matters.


But packaging, storytelling, influencers, retail environment, prestige, trends, and how a product makes us feel matter too.


Consumer research shows that price itself can influence perceived quality, particularly when consumers have limited objective information about a product. When more meaningful product information becomes available, the influence of price on perceived quality can decrease.


That, to me, is the important part.


I am certainly not suggesting that we stop creating prestige beauty products or stop developing exciting new innovations. That would be a strange position for someone involved in new product development.


What I am suggesting is awareness.


Understand what you are buying.


Understand which benefits matter to you.


Understand what is supported by evidence and what is primarily part of the experience.


Then decide whether that experience is worth the money to you.


So, Is Prestige Beauty Worth It?


If you can comfortably afford it, love using it, and appreciate the formulation, packaging, experience, or brand—absolutely. Enjoy it.


But if buying that $200 cream means you are going to use half a pea-sized amount every fourth Tuesday because you're terrified of running out, I would probably choose something more affordable.


My preference?


Buy good products you can consistently use, from companies you trust, that address what your skin actually needs.


Then if you want to splurge occasionally because something is innovative, beautiful, luxurious, or simply makes you happy?


Go for it.


Just know what you're paying for.


And if you are on the other side of the equation, developing a beauty brand, I think there is an equally important lesson here.


Consumers deserve products whose value we can actually explain.


At Peachtree Beauty, we would love to work with entrepreneurs who want to build genuinely useful, responsible, and effective products, and brands that create value rather than simply benefiting from consumer confusion.


Have an idea for something worth creating?


Let's brainstorm together. We'd love to hear it.





References & Further Reading


Xu S, Kwa M, Lohman ME, Evers-Meltzer R, Silverberg JI. “Consumer Preferences, Product Characteristics, and Potentially Allergenic Ingredients in Best-selling Moisturizers.” JAMA Dermatology. 2017;153(11):1099–1105. JAMA Network


Hughes MCB, Williams GM, Baker P, Green AC. “Sunscreen and Prevention of Skin Aging: A Randomized Trial.” Annals of Internal Medicine. 2013;158(11):781–790. PubMed


American Academy of Dermatology. “How to Select Anti-Aging Skin Care Products” and “How to Maximize Results from Anti-Aging Skin Care Products.” American Academy of Dermatology


Gerstner E. “Do Higher Prices Signal Higher Quality?” Journal of Product Innovation Management. 1985;22(2). The analysis found that for many products the relationship between price and measured quality was weak. Sage Journals

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page